23 Unforgettable Songs From Plays That Will Haunt You

Have you ever left a theatre humming a tune, wishing you could relive that magical moment? The best songs from plays aren't just catchy melodies; they're emotional anchors, transporting us back to pivotal scenes and unforgettable characters. From Broadway blockbusters to lesser-known gems, musical theatre boasts a treasure trove of songs that transcend the stage and resonate deeply long after the curtain falls. This list delves into the captivating world of musical theatre, exploring songs that have stood the test of time and captivated audiences worldwide. Whether you're a seasoned theatre aficionado or simply a lover of great music, this curated selection of the best songs from plays promises a journey through some of the most memorable and emotionally resonant tunes ever written. Prepare to rediscover old favorites and unearth some hidden gems that will leave you wanting more.

23 Unforgettable Songs From Plays That Will Haunt You
SongArtistAlbumListens
1. Circle of Life The Lion King Cast 64M+
2. Summer Nights Grease Cast 59M+
3. You're The One That I Want John Travolta
Olivia Newton-John
Get The Knack 59M+
4. Think Of Me Patrick Wilson
Andrew Lloyd Webber
Emmy Rossum
The Phantom Of The Opera (Original Motion Picture Soundtrack) 32M+
5. If I Were a Rich Man Fiddler on the Roof Cast 25M+
6. Non-Stop Hamilton Cast 21M+
7. America West Side Story Cast 9M+

1. Circle of Life

Memorable Vocals: The iconic vocals of the Lion King cast, particularly Elton John's powerful delivery, perfectly capture the sweeping emotion of the opening scene and set a majestic tone for the entire musical.

Orchestral Grandeur: Hans Zimmer's score elevates "Circle of Life" beyond a simple song; the powerful orchestral arrangements create a truly cinematic listening experience that's perfectly suited to the theatrical production.

Theatrical Impact: The song's triumphant, uplifting melody and lyrics perfectly encapsulate the celebratory and life-affirming spirit of the play, making it a show-stopping opener that immediately grabs the audience's attention.

Circle of Life - The Lion King Cast

2. Summer Nights - 1971

Memorable Duet: "Summer Nights" masterfully weaves together the perspectives of Sandy and Danny, creating a captivating back-and-forth that's both romantic and playfully competitive, showcasing the talents of Olivia Newton-John and John Travolta.

Upbeat Tempo and Catchy Melody: The song's infectious rhythm and memorable melody make it instantly enjoyable and contribute significantly to its lasting popularity beyond the confines of the stage.

Iconic Pop Culture Status: Its inclusion in the mega-hit musical *Grease* solidified "Summer Nights" as a timeless classic, instantly recognizable and frequently reprised in various media, making it a quintessential example of a song achieving broader cultural impact beyond its theatrical roots.

Summer Nights - Grease Cast

3. You're The One That I Want (John Travolta ft Olivia Newton-John - 1978)

Iconic Duet: "You're The One That I Want" features the unforgettable voices of John Travolta and Olivia Newton-John, perfectly capturing the playful energy of the Grease soundtrack.

Upbeat Rhythm: Its catchy melody and irresistible rhythm make it a quintessential feel-good song, instantly recognizable and endlessly replayable.

Enduring Legacy: This track remains a staple of musical theatre and pop culture, its enduring popularity a testament to its infectious energy and timeless appeal.

You're The One That I Want - John Travolta,Olivia Newton-John

4. Think Of Me - The Phantom Of The Opera (Original Motion Picture Soundtrack)

Vocal Performance: Emmy Rossum's haunting vocals deliver a powerful emotional punch, perfectly capturing Christine's vulnerability and longing.

Orchestral Arrangement: Andrew Lloyd Webber's masterful orchestration creates a lush, romantic soundscape that enhances the song's dramatic impact, making it a standout moment in the musical.

Theatrical Impact: "Think of Me" is a showstopper, frequently used in stage productions to showcase the soprano's vocal capabilities and set the emotional tone of the Phantom of the Opera.

Think Of Me - Patrick Wilson,Andrew Lloyd Webber,Emmy Rossum

5. If I Were a Rich Man

Memorable Melody: "If I Were a Rich Man" boasts an instantly recognizable and infectiously upbeat melody that perfectly captures Tevye's yearning and whimsical fantasy.

Iconic Performance: Zero Mostel's original performance is legendary, setting the standard for comedic and heartfelt delivery within the context of a musical theatre piece.

Enduring Appeal: The song's universal themes of longing and aspiration continue to resonate with audiences, making it a timeless classic from the world of musical theatre.

If I Were a Rich Man - Fiddler on the Roof Cast

6. Non-Stop (2015)

Upbeat Energy: "Non-Stop" from the Hamilton cast delivers an infectious energy that perfectly captures the show's dynamic pace and relentless drive.

Ensemble Vocals: The song showcases the incredible vocal talents of the entire ensemble cast, creating a powerful and unified sound.

Memorable Melody: Its catchy melody and rhythmic complexity make it a standout track, easily remembered and hummed long after the curtain falls, solidifying its place amongst great musical theatre numbers.

Non-Stop - Hamilton Cast

7. America

Lyrical Depth: "America" masterfully captures the complexities of assimilation and cultural identity, exploring both the allure and disillusionment of the American Dream through its poignant lyrics.

Orchestral Power: The song's memorable score, a vibrant blend of jazz and classical influences, elevates the emotional impact, perfectly reflecting the energy and tension of the play.

Vocal Performance: The powerful vocals of the West Side Story cast deliver a captivating performance, conveying the characters' internal conflicts and desires with raw intensity, making it a truly unforgettable theatrical experience.

America - West Side Story Cast

8. Memory (Elaine Paige - 1981)

Vocal Performance: Elaine Paige's soaring vocals in "Memory" are legendary, showcasing incredible power and emotional depth perfectly suited to the dramatic context of the musical.

Emotional Impact: The song's melancholic yet hopeful melody and lyrics evoke a profound sense of longing and reflection, making it a truly unforgettable theatrical moment.

Theatrical Context: "Memory" transcends its stage origins, becoming a powerful standalone ballad that encapsulates the emotional weight and dramatic arc often found in the best musical theatre.

Memory - Elaine Paige

9. One Day More - 1985

Vocal Performances: "One Day More" showcases the incredible vocal talent of the entire Les Misérables ensemble cast, creating a powerful and unforgettable choral experience.

Emotional Resonance: The song masterfully builds tension and anticipation, reflecting the characters' internal struggles and the escalating conflict, leaving a lasting emotional impact on the listener.

Dramatic Build: The layered harmonies and increasing tempo of "One Day More" create a dramatic arc that mirrors the rising stakes within the play itself, making it a perfect example of musical storytelling within a theatrical context.

One Day More - Les Misérables Cast

10. Defying Gravity (2003)

Powerhouse Vocals: Kristin Chenoweth and Idina Menzel's soaring voices perfectly capture the emotional intensity of this iconic musical theatre number.

Anthemic Quality: "Defying Gravity" boasts a powerful melody and driving rhythm that makes it instantly memorable and deeply satisfying to sing along to.

Emotional Resonance: The song's themes of self-discovery and breaking free resonate deeply with audiences, making it a timeless favorite from the stage.

Defying Gravity - Kristin Chenoweth,Idina Menzel
  • Ol' Man River
    11

    Ol' Man River

    Paul Robeson

    1927

  • Cabaret
    12

    Cabaret

    Liza Minnelli

    1966

  • Don't Cry for Me Argentina
    13

    Don't Cry for Me Argentina

    Evita Cast

    1976

  • Music of the Night
    14

    Music of the Night

    Michael Crawford

    1986

  • I'm Gonna Wash That Man Right Out of My Hair
    15

    I'm Gonna Wash That Man Right Out of My Hair

    South Pacific Cast

    1949

  • Seasons of Love
    16

    Seasons of Love

    Rent Cast

    1996

  • This Is the Hour
    17

    This Is the Hour

    Miss Saigon Cast

    1989

  • High Flying Adored
    18

    High Flying Adored

    Evita Cast

    1976

  • A Little Priest
    19

    A Little Priest

    Sweeney Todd Cast

    1979

  • Rose's Turn
    20

    Rose's Turn

    Angela Lansbury,Patti LuPone,Ethel Merman, Bernadette Peters

    1959

  • Aquarius
    21

    Aquarius

    Hair Cast

    1967

  • Superstar
    22

    Superstar

    Jesus Christ Superstar Cast

    1970

  • Any Dream Will Do
    23

    Any Dream Will Do

    Joseph Cast

    1968