Is there anything more deliciously wicked than the dark comedy and killer tunes of Heathers the Musical? If you're a fan, you know the struggle is real when trying to pick just one favorite song. This list tackles that very dilemma, diving headfirst into the deliciously dark and surprisingly catchy soundtrack to uncover the true best songs from Heathers the Musical. From the instantly iconic "Candy Store" to the heartbreaking balladry of other tracks, we'll explore the musical numbers that cemented this show's place in the hearts (and playlists) of theatre lovers everywhere. Whether you're a seasoned Heather fanatic or just discovering the show's subversive charm, get ready to debate, reminisce, and maybe even add a few new tracks to your ultimate power ballad playlist. This isn't just a ranking; it's a journey through the emotional rollercoaster that is Heathers the Musical, exploring the songs that perfectly capture its unique blend of humor, heartbreak, and social commentary. So, grab your scrunchies and let's get started!
| Song | Artist | Album | Listens |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Meant to Be Yours | Ryan McCartan | 22M+ | |
| 2. Beautiful |
Cast Barrett Wilbert Weed | 12M+ | |
| 3. Our Love is God |
Barrett Wilbert Weed Ryan McCartan | 10M+ | |
| 4. Dead Girl Walking |
Barrett Wilbert Weed Ryan McCartan | Heathers the Musical (Original West End Cast Recording) | 9M+ |
| 5. Never Shut Up Again | Dominic Andersen | 3M+ | |
| 6. Fight for Me | Barrett Wilbert Weed | 2M+ | |
| 7. The Me Inside of Me |
Barrett Wilbert Weed Jessica Keenan Wynn | 2M+ |
1. Meant to Be Yours - 2025
Vocal Performance: Ryan McCartan delivers a powerful and emotive performance, showcasing his vocal range and conveying the raw emotion of the character J.D.
Memorable Melody: The song's catchy and haunting melody stays with you long after you've heard it, perfectly capturing the dark romanticism of the musical.
Theatrical Impact: "Meant to Be Yours" is a standout number in the musical, effectively using its dynamic arrangement to build tension and showcase J.D.'s manipulative charm.
2. Beautiful (2014)
Vocal Performance: Barrett Wilbert Weed delivers a captivating performance, showcasing the character's vulnerability and strength with stunning vocal control.
Emotional Resonance: "Beautiful" captures the bittersweet complexities of teenage romance and self-discovery, resonating deeply with the emotional arc of *Heathers*.
Orchestration: The song's delicate yet powerful orchestration perfectly complements the lyrics, enhancing the overall emotional impact and creating a memorable listening experience.
3. Our Love is God
Power Ballad Perfection: "Our Love Is God" delivers a soaring, emotionally resonant performance from Barrett Wilbert Weed and Ryan McCartan, showcasing the vocal talent of both performers within the context of *Heathers*.
Thematic Resonance: The song masterfully captures the intense, almost obsessive, nature of young love and its connection to the show's dark themes.
Unforgettable Melody: Its memorable melody and powerful lyrics ensure it stays with you long after the curtain falls, solidifying its place as a *Heathers* standout.
4. Dead Girl Walking - Heathers the Musical (Original West End Cast Recording)
Vocals: Barrett Wilbert Weed delivers a chillingly captivating performance, perfectly embodying the character's dark wit and underlying vulnerability.
Musical Arrangement: The song's blend of dark pop and theatrical elements creates a uniquely unsettling yet catchy sound that stays with you long after the music ends.
Theatrical Impact: "Dead Girl Walking" is a standout moment in *Heathers the Musical*, showcasing the show's ability to seamlessly blend humor and chilling drama.
5. Never Shut Up Again
Vocal Performance: Dominic Andersen delivers a powerful and emotive vocal performance in "Never Shut Up Again" capturing the raw intensity and defiance often present in *Heathers* characters.
Musical Arrangement: The song's driving rhythm and catchy melody perfectly complement the show's dark humor and underlying tension, making it a high-energy addition to any *Heathers* playlist.
Thematic Resonance: "Never Shut Up Again" speaks to the themes of rebellion and self-discovery prevalent in the musical, resonating with the show's overall message of standing up for oneself.
6. Fight for Me
Power Ballad Prowess: "Fight for Me" showcases Barrett Wilbert Weed's incredible vocal range and emotional depth, perfectly capturing the raw intensity of the Heathers storyline.
Memorable Melody: The song's soaring melody and anthemic quality make it incredibly catchy and unforgettable, sticking with you long after the final note.
Theatrical Impact: Its placement within the musical perfectly underscores the dramatic tension and emotional stakes, making it a pivotal moment in the narrative.
7. The Me Inside of Me
Haunting Vocals: Barrett Wilbert Weed and Jessica Keenan Wynn deliver chillingly beautiful harmonies that perfectly capture the song's unsettling atmosphere.
Thematic Resonance: "The Me Inside of Me" delves into the complex inner turmoil of a character grappling with identity and manipulation, a key theme within *Heathers*.
Emotional Impact: The song's crescendo and powerful lyrics leave a lasting impression, highlighting the emotional depth of the musical's characters.
8. Lifeboat
Vocal Performance: Alice Lee delivers a captivating performance in "Lifeboat" showcasing a powerful vocal range and emotional depth that perfectly captures the vulnerability and intensity of the character.
Thematic Resonance: The song's lyrics cleverly weave in the themes of desperation, control, and finding unlikely alliances, reflecting key aspects of the *Heathers* narrative with a unique twist.
Musical Arrangement: The blend of haunting melodies and driving rhythms creates a sonic landscape that's both unsettling and captivating, leaving a lasting impression.
9. I Say No (Carrie Hope Fletcher - 2025)
Vocal Performance: Carrie Hope Fletcher's powerful vocals perfectly capture the defiance and vulnerability of Veronica Sawyer in this pivotal moment of the show.
Thematic Resonance: "I Say No" masterfully encapsulates the themes of rebellion and self-discovery central to *Heathers*, making it a standout track in the musical.
Memorable Melody: The song's catchy melody and strong rhythm make it instantly unforgettable, further solidifying its place as a fan favorite.
10. Big Fun - 2025
Upbeat Energy: "Big Fun" explodes with infectious energy, perfectly capturing the manic, darkly comedic tone of *Heathers*. The driving rhythm and catchy melody are impossible not to tap your feet to.
Vocal Harmonies: The vocal harmonies between Cast, Jon Eidson, and Evan Todd are a highlight, adding layers of complexity and showcasing their impressive range.
Memorable Lyricism: The lyrics are both witty and darkly insightful, reflecting the show's sharp satire and cynical humor while maintaining a sense of fun.
11Kindergarten Boyfriend
Katie Ladner
2014
12Freeze Your Brain
Ryan McCartan
2014
13Seventeen
Barrett Wilbert Weed,Ryan McCartan
2014
Little Shop Of Horrors - New Broadway Cast
14I Will Never Shut Up Again
Dominic Andersen
2018
15Blue
Jon Eidson, Evan Todd
2014
16Candy Store
Jessica Keenan Wynn,Alice Lee,Elle McLemore
2014
Little Shop Of Horrors - New Broadway Cast